News Summary
Goodies Eatery, a beloved breakfast and sandwich shop in downtown Tallahassee, will close after 38 years of service. Owner John Henningsen announced the closure will take place on May 30 due to unforeseen circumstances from structural enhancements needed in the building. The establishment has been a community staple known for its friendly service and specialty menu items, leaving many customers nostalgic as they prepare for its final days.
TALLAHASSEE – Goodies Eatery to Close After 38 Years of Service
Goodies Eatery, a well-loved breakfast and sandwich shop located at 116 E. College Ave. in downtown Tallahassee, is set to close its doors permanently after 38 years of operation. The announcement was made by owner John Henningsen on May 12, who described the closure as the “end of an era.” The last day for customers to enjoy their meals at Goodies will be May 30.
The closure follows a call from Henningsen’s landlords just two weeks prior, advising him that he would need to halt operations due to unforeseen circumstances. The building that houses Goodies, previously known as Westcott Station, is owned by Capitol Corner LLC, which is managed by The Southern Group, a lobbying firm led by Paul Bradshaw. A spokesperson for Capitol Corner has indicated that necessary structural enhancements requiring heavy construction will affect the space occupied by Goodies, prompting the closure.
Reflections on a Local Landmark
Goodies Eatery has been a staple in the Tallahassee community, known for its specialty sandwiches, quiches, and friendly customer service. Since its establishment in May 1995, Henningsen has created a welcoming environment where cherished memories were shared, such as raising his children while managing the eatery and engaging in conversations with guests. Over the years, Goodies has become a popular spot for local events and gatherings, often catering for significant occasions, including the Associated Press’s “AP Day.” The establishment was an integral part of the community, having partnered with Lucky Goat Coffee to enhance its offerings.
A Loyal Customer Base
Henningsen has built a regular patronage over nearly four decades, with approximately 80% of his customers being loyal visitors. He expressed gratitude for the support received from his customers and staff throughout the years. The impact of the closure extends beyond just business hours; it is a significant change for the numerous employees and regular customers who have formed bonds within the establishment. Since the announcement, community members have begun visiting the shop to share their well wishes and express their sadness at its impending closure on social media.
Transitioning Forward
Despite the unexpected nature of the closure, Henningsen is optimistic about the future. He acknowledged that while it is difficult to close a chapter that has been such a vital part of his life, he believes this transition may open up new opportunities ahead. Henningsen started Goodies without any prior culinary experience, having created a business plan with local restaurateurs and securing a commercial loan. His commitment and passion led him to serve various well-known figures, including Florida governors and celebrities such as Adam Sandler.
A Legacy of Community Connection
The closing of Goodies Eatery marks a significant event in Tallahassee, as it has not only provided nourishing breakfast and lunch options but also fostered a sense of community among its patrons. Generations of Tallahassee residents have dined at Goodies, making it more than just a restaurant but an establishment whose legacy will resonate in the memories of those who frequented it.
As the final days approach, many are left reminiscing about their experiences at Goodies and the lasting impression it has made on the local culture. Henningsen’s tenure at Goodies has solidified its place as a beloved part of Tallahassee’s history and community spirit.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- Tallahassee Democrat: Goodies Eatery to Close After 38 Years of Service
- Tallahassee Democrat: 5 Places to Celebrate Cinco de Mayo
- Tallahassee Democrat: First Jack in the Box Slated for Tallahassee
- Florida Politics: TSG Advisors Bags a Prized Corner in Downtown Tallahassee
- WTXL: Tallahassee Community to Get New Mural
- Wikipedia: Tallahassee
- Google Search: Tallahassee Restaurants
- Google Scholar: Tallahassee Community Restaurants
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Tallahassee
- Google News: Tallahassee News
